Photoelectrochemical (PEC) hydrogen production holds great promise for applications in energy production. A novel strategy characterized by simplicity, stability, and high efficiency was developed to significantly boost the PEC performance of TiO2 (anatase) nanotube arrays (TNTAs). This strategy entailed a series of treatments, including a conventional anodic oxidation (etching) process, a primary annealing treatment, and a secondary annealing treatment via impregnation. As a result, Nickel phosphide (Ni2P) was composited onto well-ordered titanium dioxide (anatase) nanotube array photoanodes (Ni2P/TNTAs), which exhibit hugely improved PEC hydrogen generation performance. A thorough and systematic investigation was conducted to comprehensively analyze the morphology, semiconductor band-gap structure, and PEC hydrogen production performance of the Ni2P/TNTAs composites. The experimental results demonstrated that under identical experimental circumstances, the measured photocurrent density of the Ni2P/TNTAs photoanode exhibited a 6.63-fold increase relative to that of the TNTAs. The hydrogen production rate of Ni2P/TNTAs reaches 182.96 μmol/cm2, 6.10 times higher than that of the pure TNTAs. The excellent interfacial charge transfer pathway at the Ni2P/TiO2 interface promoted photogenerated carrier separation and electron transfer from TiO2 to Ni2P. This method offers a valuable reference for designing highly efficient PEC hydrogen-production catalysts.